Coming off big election wins in the mid-terms, Democrats at the state level have apparently decided to make good on campaign promises to address “affordability”. Not by dismantling the bureaucracies they spent so many years making, but by paying off traditional Democratic interest groups. According to the Wall Street Journal, in the bluest states where the Democrats won both the Gubernatorial vote as well as the state legislature, the plans include
“… subsidizing child care and housing construction, expanding tax credits for parents and other caregivers, using state funds to forgive medical debt, and offering free meals to more students.”
How those measures are supposed to promote “affordability” outside of being part of an interest group, is anybody’s guess. They just mean more government spending to subsidize excess demand from certain groups like students, teachers and borrowers. Nowhere is there any suggestion that any of this produces costs.
Oh but, “the rich” can pay–because wait for it –“They can afford it”. The assumption being that “the rich” have their money (e.g., capital) safely ensconced under the mattress rather than working productively to create new goods and services.
According to the conventional wisdom, (which is almost invariably wrong because the conventional wisdom incorporates so many popular myths) Democrats and Republicans differ on how to define rich, with the definition almost entirely dependent on where to draw the line on the threshold for taxation. The real difference is that Democrats prefer coercion (government); whereas Republicans (of the past) prefer market solutions.
The where to draw the line question is different. It comes into play almost entirely because we have a progressive (federal) tax system. Essentially, the question wouldn’t matter if we had a flat tax. But because we have a steeply progressive tax system (much steeper than is typical for Europe by the way) we get to play the Huey Long game of “Don’t tax you, don’t tax me. Tax the man behind the tree.” Which is to say that the current tax system is a massive exercise in cost shifting.
For instance, the household that earns $500,000 a year, (which is 10 times the $50,000 household) pays 58 times as much in federal income tax. For every “free” benefit that government provides, somebody has to pay for it. And it is the “rich” which comes at the expense of productivity and innovation.
So now the question becomes not one of public goods provision, or even the financing of public goods, but a question of efficiency. Which entity is more capable of producing public services at the least cost, the public or private sector?
The airport controller system — the one that shut down the other day–is run by government. Here is a critique of the system expressed 30 years ago by the Congressman lefties love to hate–Newt Gingrich.
“The United States Government is the largest purchaser of vacuum tubes in the Western world. This is a Federal Aviation Administration vacuum tube. Good, solid 1895 technology. This is the updated mid-1950s version. When you fly in America, vacuum tubes in the air-traffic control system keep you safe. Our purchasing rules are so complicated and so wasteful that our government has not been able in seven years to figure out how to replace vacuum tubes with this. This is a microchip that has the computing power of three million vacuum tubes. So today’s government operates this way.”
So there you have it. The US air traffic control system relies (relied) on vacuum tubes.
Not that the school system is so different. The US comes in close to the bottom in international competitions largely because the teachers unions resist having competitors to public schools. In a classic case of regulatory capture, Virginia’s governor, the alleged “moderate ” Abigail Spanberger, decided to opt out of the federal school choice tax credit. So Virginia’s students will not be able to receive support from the state’s taxpayers. Those funds (assuming they materialize) will be designated for students in other states.
Democrats alone are not the only ones who have contributed to this fiasco. However they have no limiting principal they can point to. Republicans , do have one; but they honor it only in the breech, especially the one named Donald Trump. Despite all the finger-pointing, the Republicans have contributed mightily to the impending catastrophe. Democrats did not build up that $40 trillion in accumulated debt all by themselves; they had plenty of help.
The Republicans richly deserved the spanking they got from the electorate. But we didn’t deserve what we got as a result. Or did we?
JFB